Explainer

The Email Deliverability Checklist: 21 Things to Fix Before You Hit Send

A black-and-white cutout of a clipboard with a checklist and a pen on a flat mint-green background

Most deliverability problems are not mysteries. They are one of about twenty known causes, each of which can be checked in a few minutes and most of which can be fixed in an afternoon. Senders who land in spam usually skipped three or four of them, not because the checks are hard, but because nobody wrote them down in order.

Here they are, written down in order. Twenty-one items in five groups: authentication, list hygiene, content, infrastructure, and the final pass before you hit send. Work top to bottom. The early items carry the most weight with Gmail, Yahoo, and Microsoft, so if you only have an hour, spend it on the first ten.

Key takeaways

  • Authentication first: SPF, DKIM, and DMARC must pass and align with your From domain, or nothing else on this list matters.
  • List hygiene second: remove every bounce, unsubscribe, and complaint before each send. Bounces under 2%, complaints under 0.1%.
  • Content and infrastructure are tiebreakers. They decide placement only once the first two groups are clean.
  • Print the list, tape it next to the send button, and run it every time. The cleaning step takes about seven minutes.

Authentication (items 1 to 5)

These prove to the receiving server that the mail really came from you. Gmail and Yahoo require all three records for bulk senders, and a failure here is a silent trip to spam.

  1. SPF record published. One TXT record on your domain listing every service allowed to send for it, ending in ~all or -all. Check that your email platform's include is present and that the record stays under the 10-lookup limit.
  2. DKIM signing enabled. Your platform signs each message with a key published in your DNS. Most platforms call this "domain authentication" and hand you two or three CNAME records to add. Confirm the status reads verified.
  3. DMARC record published. A TXT record at _dmarc.yourdomain.com. Start with p=none and a reporting address so you can see what fails before you enforce anything.
  4. Alignment confirmed. The domain in your visible From address matches the domain SPF or DKIM authenticated. Sending from [email protected] while DKIM signs as mail.platform.com fails DMARC alignment even when both records are valid.
  5. Reverse DNS on the sending IP. Your platform handles this on shared IPs. If you run a dedicated IP or your own server, the IP must resolve to a hostname that resolves back to the IP.

The plain-English version of all five is in SPF, DKIM, and DMARC for email marketers.

List hygiene (items 6 to 11)

Authentication proves who you are. Hygiene proves you are worth letting in. These six items move your reputation faster than anything else you control.

  1. Hard bounces removed since the last send. Export the bounced or cleaned contacts from your platform and suppress them. Every repeat send to a dead address is a mark against you.
  2. Unsubscribes and complaints suppressed across every tool. If you send from two platforms, or a CRM and a newsletter tool, an unsubscribe in one must be removed from the other. Merge the files; the merging guide shows how.
  3. Repeat soft bounces removed. Any address that soft-bounced on three or more consecutive sends is an abandoned inbox. Treat it as hard.
  4. Role and disposable addresses handled. Suppress postmaster@, abuse@, and noreply@ outright. Segment or suppress other role accounts and any address at a known burner domain.
  5. Inactive subscribers sunset or segmented. No opens or clicks in 12 months means no sends until they respond to a re-engagement message. Mailing the silent drags down engagement for everyone.
  6. No purchased, scraped, or borrowed addresses. If anyone on the list did not ask you, personally, to write to them, take them off before they take you off.

Items 6 to 9 are one operation. Upload your full list and your bounce, unsubscribe, complaint, role, and disposable files to Email List Refresh, and download the original CSV with every column intact and the suppressed rows gone. Run it before every campaign.

A clean pass looks like this. Authentication at 100% in Postmaster Tools, bounce rate under 1% on a freshly cleaned list, complaints under 0.1%, one-click unsubscribe working, seed messages in the inbox at all four providers. Senders who hit those marks rarely think about deliverability again, which is the point.

Content (items 12 to 16)

Content filters are weaker than they were a decade ago, but a few things still trip them, and a few others quietly cost you engagement, which the providers weigh heavily.

  1. Working unsubscribe link in the body, plus List-Unsubscribe headers. The link must work in one or two clicks and honor the request within two days. Bulk senders to Gmail and Yahoo also need the one-click header; your platform adds it if you let it.
  2. Physical mailing address in the footer. Required by CAN-SPAM for any commercial message. A P.O. box or registered mail drop is fine.
  3. Subject line that matches the body. No "Re:" on a first message, no fake forward, no "URGENT" in capitals. Mismatches produce complaints, and complaints produce filtering.
  4. Text-to-image balance and a plain-text part. A single large image with 20 words of text looks like a spammer dodging filters. Include real text and let your platform generate the plain-text version.
  5. Links point where they say and use your domain. No public URL shorteners, no mismatched link text, no links to domains with a poor reputation. If your platform tracks clicks, set up a branded tracking domain so the links carry your name.

Item 12 matters more than the other four combined. A subscriber who cannot find the exit presses the spam button, and that is the worse outcome by a wide margin.

  1. Check authentication

    Confirm SPF, DKIM, and DMARC are published and that the From domain aligns with the authenticated domain. Fix any failure before touching the list.

  2. Export the suppression files

    From your platform, export bounces, unsubscribes, and complaints since the last send. Add role and disposable address files if you have them.

  3. Clean the list

    Upload your full contact list with the suppression files, download the cleaned CSV with every column intact, and re-import it.

  4. Review the content items

    Confirm the unsubscribe link, physical address, honest subject line, text balance, and branded links.

  5. Read the reports and send a seed test

    Check Postmaster Tools and the last campaign report, send to your own accounts at the major providers, and only then send to the list.

Infrastructure and sending behavior (items 17 to 19)

How you send carries almost as much signal as what you send.

  1. Steady volume and cadence. A list that receives 25,000 messages every Tuesday looks like a newsletter. A list that receives nothing for six weeks and then 25,000 on a Saturday looks like a compromised account. If you must change volume, change it by no more than half per week.
  2. New domain or IP warmed up. Start a new sending domain at a few hundred messages a day to your most engaged subscribers and roughly double each week over four to six weeks. Do not send to the full list on day one.
  3. Marketing on its own subdomain. Send campaigns from news.yourcompany.com and keep yourcompany.com for invoices, support, and one-to-one mail. A bad campaign week then cannot touch the messages that keep the business running.

These three are set-and-forget. Once cadence, warm-up, and the subdomain are in place, they stay in place until you change platforms.

The final pass before you hit send (items 20 and 21)

Two checks, five minutes, every time.

  1. Postmaster Tools and the last campaign report reviewed. Open Google Postmaster Tools and your platform's most recent report. Bounce rate under 2%, complaint rate under 0.1%, domain reputation medium or high, authentication at 100%. If any one of them is off, fix it before this send, not after.
  2. Seed test sent and read. Send the final version to your own accounts at Gmail, Yahoo, Outlook, and iCloud. Confirm it lands in the inbox or promotions tab, every link works, the unsubscribe works, and the sender name and address look right on a phone.

Then send. Afterward, note the bounce and complaint figures so item 20 has something to compare against next time. The benchmarks guide tells you what the numbers should look like for a list your size.

Where to start if you can only fix three things

If the whole list feels like too much for this week, do these three and come back for the rest.

PriorityItemTimeWhy first
1Items 1 to 4: authenticate and align1 to 2 hours, onceRequired by Gmail and Yahoo; unauthenticated bulk mail is rejected or spammed outright
2Items 6 and 7: suppress bounces, unsubscribes, complaintsAbout 7 minutes, every sendThe fastest-moving reputation inputs, and the only ones that get worse with every send you skip
3Item 12: unsubscribe link and one-click header15 minutes, onceConverts future complaints into harmless unsubscribes

Everything else on the checklist improves placement. These three decide whether you have any. A fuller account of what the providers weigh and how fast they react is in sender reputation explained.

Free estimate

See what this costs your list

Pick your list size. We will show you the math, then send you a one-page cleanup plan for your platform.

Your estimatePick a list size and platform to see the numbers.
—addresses likely dead this year
—paid per year to store them
—contacts that can still be reached

No spam, no list rental. One email with your plan, then nothing unless you ask.

FAQ

Questions about email deliverability checklist

What is an email deliverability checklist?

An email deliverability checklist is an ordered set of checks a sender runs before a campaign to make sure the message reaches the inbox rather than the spam folder. A complete one covers authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC), list hygiene (bounces, unsubscribes, complaints, inactive addresses), content (unsubscribe link, physical address, honest subject line), sending infrastructure (cadence, warm-up, subdomain), and a final review of reputation data and a seed test.

How do I improve email deliverability quickly?

Three things move the needle within a week. Authenticate and align SPF, DKIM, and DMARC for your From domain. Remove every bounced, unsubscribed, and complaining address from your list before the next send. Add a working one-click unsubscribe. After that, mail only your engaged subscribers for a few sends, then widen. Most senders see bounces drop below 1% immediately and inbox placement recover within four to eight weeks.

What bounce rate and complaint rate should I aim for?

Keep hard bounces under 2% per send, and expect under 1% on a list cleaned before each campaign. Keep spam complaints under 0.1% of delivered messages; Gmail and Yahoo treat 0.3% as the point where filtering or blocking begins. Unsubscribe rates are not penalized, so a 0.5% unsubscribe rate on a send is healthy and far better than a 0.2% complaint rate.

How often should I run the deliverability checklist?

Run the authentication and infrastructure items once, then again whenever you change platforms, domains, or sending volume. Run the list hygiene items before every campaign, or monthly at minimum if you send less often. Run the content items and the final pass every single time you send. The whole recurring portion takes about 15 minutes once the exports are routine.

Does list cleaning really affect deliverability?

Yes, and it is the fastest input you control. Inbox providers count every message to a nonexistent address as evidence of a careless or purchased list, and they count every spam complaint against your domain. Removing bounces and complainers before each send cuts both numbers at once. Authentication gets you through the door; a clean list is what keeps you there.

Clean your list before the next send.

Upload your contacts and every suppression file you have. Download a clean CSV with every column intact. Seven minutes, start to finish.

Envelopes drop into a funnel: good addresses stack up, bad ones are thrown out